內地節目評判崔健，批評許志安好out用廣東歌參賽

machihck

from Jamie sun

我覺得若果你係評論首歌唔岩佢唱，佢唱唔到果種感覺，我覺得呢d評論係正常，講真大陸歌唱比賽好多歌我都冇聽過，都係聽下d人唱成點有冇感情果d, 有好多可能係因為歌唱比賽唱紅左一首唔hit既歌, 而唔係好似呢個評審咁，佢既評論只係因為佢唔識首歌，都痴L線，你好唔好意思講比人知你一把年紀連"怎麼捨得你"都唔識，大佬呀, 人地張學友雪狼湖唱左幾百場你都唔識，你好唔好意思學人做評審講自己係音樂人? OK你唔識冇人怪你，你唔好拎出黎講HIN醜啦~~ 雖然許志安係把聲有少少沙, 但我覺得佢唱呢首歌真係用心歌唔係HEA唱而且係唱得好有感情架喎~~


https://www.facebook.com/passivenews/videos/402198343238011/

audiophile_ed

CHING, 大陸li d 節目，10有 8,9 系想做效果出黎。。。何必太認真。

而且，崔健講真，一個從來無系主流樂壇混過gei人，真心覺得佢系唔適合去評流行曲。。。根本揾錯評判。  

Soundboy

First of all, I am not a fan of Andy Hui's.  Regardless, I still don't understand why he have to enter a singing contest.  What does he have to prove?

I have seen some of these so-called singing contests and most of the Taiwanese/mainland Chinese judges have no idea what they are talking about.  Just because they are sitting in a judge's chair doesn't mean they know what is going on.  As for 崔健, just for his comment, he has lost any respect I have of him.

audiophile_ed

Soundboy 發表於 2015-11-30 16:21
First of all, I am not a fan of Andy Hui's.  Regardless, I still don't understand why he have to ent ...

It's just a show....

Sure Andy get pay a lot for this show.

This show are all staged and is a set-up.

Cogor

有冇搞錯，廣東歌在中國樂壇有重要地位，不遜於國語歌，有重要貢獻，好多國內同胞咪一樣聽廣東歌，廣東人絕對支持廣東歌
(Post76 Android 手機版送出)

ykluk

唔好咁認真對待呢啲事情啦~~~ 講真唔係發生咁既評論, 你又唔會post出嚟, 我又唔會睇到~~ 我又唔會知許志安上咗大陸比賽節目, 評判係崔健, 林憶蓮同劉歡~~ 我又唔會知有咁既節目~~~~

製作組同marketing做得幾好~~!!! {:9_426:}

CPU

這些所謂真人show，連觀眾都有劇本（表情，動作），所以成件事好假，不看也擺！

takeishi

  唔駛咁認真~當睇戲咁睇.
你睇台下面d人既面情真係誇到呢...........就知. 根本就係一場戲
台下既人表情重誇過北韓人民............

jumpingjack

machihck 發表於 2015-11-30 18:15
唔知真定假，不過我唔㩒激～～所以好很嬲

不過網上評語好正～～～from terry young  --當時就應 ...